Last time we looked at the ending of Superman (1979) and showed how all the people who laughed at Superman turning back the Earth to turn back time were WRONG! Ha. Egg on your faces, eh?
Well, this time we’re going even further into movie mistakes to show that they were actually not mistakes at all. In fact, this is the big daddy of all movie mistakes! We are of course talking about HIGHLANDER (1985)!

WARNING — SPOILERS AHEAD! ABANDON ALL HOPE! WOMEN AND CHILDREN FIRST!
This outrageous spot of casting saw Scottish former James Bond Sean Connery cast as the immortal Spanish Egyptian Juan Sanchez Villalobos Ramirez, while non-English speaking Frenchman Christopher Lambert plays the Scottish highlander Connor McLeod. We’re not sure what the director was smoking that day, but it must have been some pretty powerful stuff.
PRODUCER: “Hey, we’re making a film set in the highlands of Scotland and Sean Connery has just become available!”
DIRECTOR: “Great . Let’s cast him as that Spanish Egyptian guy.”
PRODUCER: “Err, okay. BUt what about the part of the Scottish clansman?”
DIRECTOR: “Get me that French guy who can’t speak a word of English.”
I’m pretty sure that was exactly the way that conversation happened.
Anyhow, some of the more eagle-eyed movie buffs among you may be wondering how can anyone explain how the most Scottish Bond ever, Sean Connery, could be a convincingly realistic choice to play a Spanish Egyptian? (what even is a Spanish Egyptian? I’m not sure. But I know they probably don’t talk like Sean Connery)
Well, wonder no more, movie lovers! Because we are about to explain why Sean Connery was in fact the PERFECT choice to play Ramirez, despite sounding like he was born in the Gorbals in Glasgow.
Think back to 1986. A time of hair bands, vinyl records, and historical accuracy in pictures…
We are first introduced to Ramirez when he almost rides over Connor and his ladyfriend in the middle of some nookie. I’m not sure exactly why Ramirez chose to leap his horse over the couple as opposed to just riding up, but then this is the director of THAT giant pig movie Razorback (Note: Razorback is a genuinely great movie about a giant pig. If you don’t believe me go check it out). Director Russell Mulcahy was fresh off music videos for bands like Ultravox and Duran Duran, so he had a right to be stylish. In any case, Ramirez dismounts and introduces himself as…
“Juan Sanchez Villalobos Ramirez, chief metallurgist to King Charles V of Spain, at your service.”
Now, this obviously raises several questions. But the biggest is: how come Sean Connery is Spanish?
Ah-ha! Plot hole, you cry!
But that is not the end of the matter. Later, during the training montage, Ramirez reveals that he was actually born in Egypt 2,700 years ago. During his lifetime he married Shakiko, a Japanese princess, whose father gave him that really nice katana sword in 592 BC.
In HIghlander II: The Quickening, Ramirez re-appears miraculously despite being killed in the first movie, and reveals that he is in fact an alien wizard. But let’s pretend that movie NEVER EXISTED AT ALL. Trust me, life is better that way.
Anyhow, forgetting the whacky sequel (not difficult) we now know that Ramirez is several thousand years old. And herein lies the clue that will reveal that this insane casting decision was in fact PURE GENIUS!

You see, it is quite possible that Ramirez travelled the world many times. In fact, he already said so. He travelled from Egypt to Japan then Spain and, presumably, many countries in between. When we see him in Scotland it is the 16th century. Now, King Charles V was kind of a big deal. In fact, he wasn’t just King of Spain. He was heir to the Hapsburg Empire, which ran from Germany to Italy, and was the Holy Roman Emperor and its Archduke. He also had numerous territories in South America. His was “the Empire upon which the sun never set”. So not an easy man to become Chief Metallurgist for by any mans, especially in a time when this position would have been extremely important in the manufacture of arms and weapons. Indeed, it would have taken a lifetime’s worth of achievement to get to that level of success within his court. Time being something Ramirez had in spades, of course.
So the explanation seems to be an easy one. Ramirez becomes interested in Europe some time between the 6th century BC and the 16th century AD. During those centuries he begins his research into metallurgy, something which would have been in its infancy in the Ancient Egyptian days. He returns to Europe from Japan, full of the knowledge he received about metallurgy from Shakiko’s father Masamune (a real person, by the way, and Medieval Japan’s most famous blacksmith). He brings his unusual knowledge to his position working in the courts of Europe and flourishes, rising up the ranks.
At some point, Spain sends Ramirez on a fact-finding mission to Britain. And who wields swords better than the Scottish highlanders? Ramirez obviously goes to Scotland to seek out more information. But here is the catch – Ramirez is used to big cities. he only goes to Edinburgh to seek out knowledge from the biggest and most famous blacksmiths in the region. Hence, he never mixes with ordinary Scottish folk. This explains why Sean Connery, the biggest Scotch actor in the world, can sit in a boat and say he has never seen a Haggis. To someone who has only ever been in the crowned courts of Europe, such a delicacy would seem horrible.
It also explains why Sean Connery has a Scottish accent. To someone immortal such as Ramirez, mingling with the comparatively wealthy Scottish folk of Edinburgh over a period of years would have rubbed off on him. Ramirez is a natural chameleon, as evidenced by the fact that he is actually Egyptian but is able to pass himself off as a Spaniard with ease. He would inevitably pick up a bit of Scots accent during his lengthy stay in Edinburgh.
After a long stay in the Scottish city, Ramirez returns to Spain. He is now a Scottish-sounding Spanish Egyptian. He then reports back his findings to King Charles V who sends him back across the sea to Scotland to strike up a lucrative trade deal with the Scottish blacksmiths for their swords.
Which brings us to the opening of the film.
So you see, what seems like an absolutely outrageous plot hole is in fact a work of astounding historical accuracy and NOT AT ALL the result of too much all-night partying at MTV during the 80s.
And you thought Highlander was just another 80s fantasy movie with beheadings and a bit of nookie, did you? Well, shame on you. It may also interest you to now that there are other bits of historical accuracy in the film. The McLeods did indeed come from the village of Glenfinnan on the shores of Lock Shiel. In fact, both the training montage and Eileann Donan Castle which feature prominently in the film are from that area near to the Isle of Skye. The Kurgans were also a real people. (Although where that dragon that the Kurgan makes a helmet out of came from is anyone’s guess. I mean, seriously, nobody even asks where got it from.)
So there you have it! PLOT HOLE EXPLAINED. Sean Connery’s casting is a Hollywood joke no more. In fact it was TOTALLY DELIBERATE and definitely not the result of too much coke binging and Duran Duran music.
I hope you enjoyed our little foray into movie madness. I actually love Highlander. It’s one of my very favourite films. So if you fancy bopping along to Queen music and watching two guys have a swordfight in Madison Square Gardens one night, you could do a lot worse than pop Highlander into the VHS player and relive the glorious 80s once more.
There can be only one (Highlander move that is, for God’s sake don’t watch the sequel)!
